

It offers the same double-sided design, a similar easy-to-apply formula, and potentially even more longevity than Anastasia Beverly Hills on some - but it does so while costing significantly less. If you’re looking for value, the NYX Micro brow pencil delivers without compromising too much on quality. If you’re looking for even more alternatives to the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz, scroll down to check out a few other great brow pencils under $20. Otherwise, NYX is a cult favorite for a reason: It delivers almost all of the same brow-defining benefits for an incredible value.

Technically, since the Brow Wiz won three categories and the Micro Pencil won two, Anastasia Beverly Hills is the winner - but only if you’re willing to pay more than double the price for a creamier application. Winner: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz - but just barely Overall, Anastasia Beverly Hills is the winner in terms of stars, but NYX isn’t too far behind. On Amazon, NYX has an average 4.6-star rating from after more than 49,000 reviews, while ABH has a 4.7-star rating after more than 20,000 customers have weighed in. If you’re looking for value, NYX has ABH beat by a mile. There’s no comparison here: At less than $9 a pencil, NYX costs significantly less than Anastasia Beverly Hills, which retails for around $25. Reviewers tend to agree: “The pigment is rich and fine and it glides so smoothly,” one wrote. PigmentationĪnastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz, is an Allure Best Of Beauty winner due to its rich yet realistic-looking color and thanks to the creamier texture, it glides on smoothly. A few users have also noted that the Blonde shade of NYX pencils can skew a little red on them, though.

One thing worth noting: NYX offers a gray shade why Anastasia Beverly Hills recommends its Ash Brown shade for gray hair. While the specific shades differ from brand to brand (and ABH only pictures 10 of them above), both offer 12 options, making this category a tie. Color Optionsīoth brow pencils offer shades that range from blonde to black, and customers appreciate the ability to match their hair color. The numbers are close, but if a long-lasting brow is the most important thing to you, it seems that Anastasia’s creamier consistency might be a downfall here. Similarly, on Amazon, NYX had a slightly higher longevity rating (4.1 stars, when compared to Anastasia’s 4 stars). When comparing user reviews from around the internet, NYX earned an 81.9% rating for longevity, while Anastasia received 81.4%. Shortly after applying, these formulas are designed for easy blending with the included spoolie - but once dried, they’re supposed to be smudge-proof and long-lasting.
#BROW ZE ANASTASIA PROFESSIONAL#
Winner: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil (It’s almost like one was trying to mimic the other.) Smudge-Resistance In terms of the width, these pencils are virtually the same thickness, though the spoolie is slightly longer and thinner on the NYX pencil. Design & Widthīoth the NYX Micro brow pencil and the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz have an ultra-slim, retractable pencil on one end and a blending spoolie on the other. This lends itself to a more natural-looking brow and more even application. According to reviewers, though, the higher-rated Anastasia Brow Wiz has a creamier, waxier consistency, making it slightly easier to apply and blend. When it comes to the NYX Micro Brow Pencil versus Anastasia Brow Wiz debate, however, it really comes down to one primary question: Are you willing to pay more for a creamier texture and easier application? Textureīoth eyebrow pencils are made in a creamy, vegan formula that glides on easily and has a matte-looking finish. At the top of the list, you’ll find two dual-sided eyebrow pencils - because they’re so similar, it’s only natural to wonder which one’s better. Eyebrows are having a much-deserved moment, which explains why the best eyebrow pencils have been getting a lot of recognition lately.
